A 29-year-old contact lens wearer sits under the triage fluorescent lights, one eye half-closed, tearing so hard the cheek is wet. He says the pain started as “grit” after an overnight shift, but now even the dim hallway light feels like a spotlight. The sclera is red, the eyelid keeps fluttering, and he can barely keep the lens story straight because he forgot to take them out. The eye looks angry in a way that makes you stop scrolling and lean in.

— What’s your move? Read on.

Before you read
  • Which finding separates simple abrasion from ulcerative infection?
  • What is the one mistake that risks permanent vision loss?

When to Think of It

Think of this when there is painful red eye + photophobia + foreign body sensation + decreased vision or a corneal opacity/infiltrate on exam. Contact lens use, trauma with vegetative matter, topical steroid use, or immunocompromise should push this to the top of the list.

Sick or Not Sick

The fork is simple epithelial defect vs. sight-threatening corneal infection/perforation risk. Any decreased vision, corneal infiltrate/opacity, hypopyon, central ulcer, contact lens wear, or severe pain/photophobia is “treat as ulcerative keratitis until proven otherwise.”

The First Fifteen Minutes

  • Topical anesthetic for exam only if needed: tetracaine 0.5% 1–2 drops in the ED to permit fluorescein/slit-lamp exam, because you need a real corneal look; do not prescribe for home use.
  • Pain control: ibuprofen 400–600 mg PO or acetaminophen 650–1,000 mg PO/IV if needed, because it improves comfort without obscuring exam findings.
  • Cycloplegic if significant ciliary spasm/photophobia: cyclopentolate 1% 1 drop or homatropine 2% 1 drop in the affected eye, because it relieves painful spasm and photophobia.
  • Suspected bacterial keratitis/corneal ulcer, especially contact lens wearer → start topical fluoroquinolone: moxifloxacin 0.5% 1 drop q1h while awake or ciprofloxacin 0.3% 1–2 drops q1h initially, because high local antibiotic levels are needed to suppress corneal pathogens.
  • If severe ulcer, central lesion, or ophthalmology directs fortified therapy: fortified tobramycin 14 mg/mL and cefazolin 50 mg/mL or vancomycin-based drops per ophthalmology protocol; dosing varies meaningfully, so check local/ophthalmology guidance.
  • If concern for herpetic keratitis (dendrites, reduced corneal sensation) → do not start topical steroids; urgent ophthalmology, because steroids can worsen HSV corneal disease.
  • Remove contact lenses immediately and bring the case/lens/case if available, because it reduces ongoing inoculation and helps identify pathogens.

Definitive Care & Disposition

Urgent ophthalmology consultation is required for any ulcer/infiltrate, visual change, hypopyon, central or large lesion, corneal thinning, immunocompromise, or inability to ensure follow-up. Small peripheral abrasions can sometimes be outpatient, but true corneal ulcer/keratitis generally gets same-day ophthalmology and often admission if severe, bilateral, atypical, or fungal/amoebic disease is suspected. Continue topical antibiotics as directed; later therapy may include culture-directed treatment, antifungals (e.g., natamycin for fungal keratitis), or anti-amoebic regimens.

How This One Kills

The fatal error is treating an infectious corneal ulcer like a routine abrasion and sending the patient away with no urgent follow-up—this can progress to corneal melt, perforation, endophthalmitis, and permanent vision loss.
The Differential — What Else Looks Like This
  • Corneal abrasion — epithelial defect without stromal infiltrate/opacity; confusing it for ulcer delays antibiotics and ophthalmology.
  • Acute glaucoma — severe pain, halos, mid-dilated fixed pupil, high IOP; confusing it for keratitis delays pressure-lowering therapy and threatens the optic nerve.
  • Anterior uveitis/iritis — consensual photophobia and ciliary flush with a quiet cornea; missing it can lead to synechiae and chronic vision loss.
  • Endophthalmitis — profound vision loss, hypopyon, post-op/injection history; missing it is catastrophic because it needs immediate intraocular therapy.

The Second-Day Story

Older adults, diabetics, and steroid-treated patients may have less dramatic pain but worse disease, and contact lens users may present late with just “irritation” and blurry vision. Any unilateral red eye with decreased visual acuity deserves fluorescein staining and slit-lamp inspection; if you see a focal infiltrate or corneal haze, assume infection until an eye specialist says otherwise.
Back to Our Patient
Back to our patient: the 29-year-old contact lens wearer with tearing, photophobia, and blurry unilateral pain gets a slit-lamp exam showing a corneal infiltrate with fluorescein uptake, so this is infectious keratitis/corneal ulcer, not a simple abrasion. Because contact lens use and decreased vision make him high risk, he goes straight into the First Fifteen with topical fluoroquinolone drops, no contact lens use, and pain control after exam, then same-day ophthalmology for culture consideration and close follow-up, with admission if the lesion is central or severe.
Patient Presentation to Attending
How you’d present this patient on the floor — tight, pertinent positives and negatives, no rambling
“29-year-old man with contact lens use presents with one day of severe left eye pain, tearing, photophobia, and blurred vision. He says it started like a scratch after a night shift, but it has worsened and he can barely tolerate light; no trauma with metal, no chemical exposure, and no headache or neurologic symptoms. On exam he has conjunctival injection, obvious discomfort, and decreased visual acuity in the affected eye; fluorescein shows a focal corneal epithelial defect with surrounding infiltrate, and I don’t see a mid-dilated fixed pupil or elevated IOP features to suggest acute glaucoma. This is most concerning for infectious keratitis/corneal ulcer, likely bacterial given the contact lens history. I’ve removed the lens, started topical fluoroquinolone drops, given analgesia, and I’m calling ophthalmology now for urgent evaluation and disposition.”

Study Directive

  • Draw the red painful eye algorithm from memory: abrasion vs keratitis vs glaucoma vs uveitis.
  • Practice naming the bedside discriminators: visual acuity change, fluorescein uptake pattern, corneal opacity, pupil shape, and IOP clues.
  • Write out the first-hour orders for a contact lens wearer with suspected ulcer: exam, lens removal, topical fluoroquinolone, analgesia, ophthalmology call.
  • Review when steroids are harmful in eye disease, especially HSV keratitis and microbial ulcers.

Recent Literature

  • Review or guideline Infectious keratitis: A review
    Cabrera-Aguas M, Khoo P, Watson SL · Clin Exp Ophthalmol, 2022 · PMID 35610943 · cited 344×
    A broad clinical review of infectious keratitis that reinforces the ED priorities: suspect it in painful red eyes with corneal staining or contact lens use, start prompt topical antimicrobial therapy when indicated, and arrange urgent ophth